Anthem Highlands heads into fall 2026 with very little competition for sellers, with only 8 homes for sale at the end of September anAnthem Highlands heads into fall 2026 with very little competition for sellers, with only 8 homes for sale at the end of September and roughly 1.6 months of supply, according to REcolorado MLS data. But buyers have more leverage on price than they did a year ago. Homes that closed this summer sold for about 94% of their original list price and averaged about 55 days on market, so pricing accuracy matters more right now than it has at any point in the last five years.
Why This Matters Right Now in Anthem Highlands
If you own a home in Anthem Highlands, you own one of the most desirable addresses in Broomfield, CO. Through the first nine months of 2026, the average sale price in the Anthem Highlands area was about $1,007,000, per MLS data. That is roughly 27% above the Broomfield citywide average of about $792,000 over the same period.
Buyer activity is strong. Forty-six homes closed in the Anthem Highlands area from January through September 2026, up from 38 over the same months in 2025. That is about a 21% increase, and it makes 2026 the busiest year for sales here since 2021.
But this fall market carries a catch that I need you to understand. Prices have not kept pace with sales volume. The year-to-date average sale price is about 5% lower than it was through September 2025, and price per square foot has held roughly flat in the low $230s. Buyers are active, but they are not overpaying.
The bigger shift is in how long homes take to sell and how much sellers give up along the way. In the third quarter of 2026, Anthem Highlands area homes averaged about 55 days on market, nearly double the roughly 29 days they averaged in the third quarter of 2025. Over that same stretch, sellers received about 94% of their original list price, compared with about 96% a year earlier. That gap tells me something very specific: homes that are priced right from day one still sell, while homes that start too high sit, take price reductions, and give up more money in the end.
I have been helping Broomfield sellers since 2017 and have closed over 125 transactions across Broomfield and Denver’s North Metro, and I can tell you this pattern always intensifies in the fall. Let me walk you through exactly what that means for your selling strategy.
Anthem Highlands Home Prices and Recent Sales Activity
You need to know where prices actually landed this summer to set realistic expectations for fall.
Here is what recent closed sales look like inside Anthem Highlands, per REcolorado MLS records:
- 3105 Blue Mountain Dr sold for $1,650,000 on 7/15/2026 (6 bed, 6,274 sq ft)
- 16036 Swan Mountain Dr sold for $1,315,000 on 7/31/2026 (6 bed, 4,928 sq ft)
- 16312 Spanish Peak Way sold for $1,100,000 on 7/29/2026 (4 bed, 4,376 sq ft)
- 16332 Spanish Peak Way sold for $1,225,000 in September 2026
- 3172 Traver Dr sold for $925,000 on 8/17/2026 (3 bed, 1,963 sq ft)
- 3394 Pacific Peak Drive sold for $795,000 in September 2026 (4 bed, 3,843 sq ft)
That is a range from $795,000 to $1,650,000. The spread is enormous, and it tells you that lot position, square footage, finishes, and whether you have Front Range mountain views or a walk-out basement all push prices dramatically in different directions.
On a price per square foot basis, monthly closed sales in the Anthem Highlands area ranged from $205 to $244 per square foot between July and September 2026, and September closings came in at $205 per square foot, per MLS data. What I tell my clients is that your specific home’s comp set matters far more than any neighborhood-wide number. A 1,963-square-foot ranch on Traver Dr is in a completely different pricing conversation than a 6,274-square-foot home on Blue Mountain Dr.
Why Fall 2026 Is a Strategic Window for Anthem Highlands Sellers
You might be wondering whether waiting until spring would be smarter. Here is why I think fall deserves serious consideration, and what it will ask of you.
Inventory is tight. Only 8 homes were listed for sale in the Anthem Highlands area at the end of September 2026, down from 11 in August and 11 in September 2025. With homes selling at a pace of about 5 per month this year, that works out to roughly 1.6 months of supply. Less competition for buyer attention is a significant advantage.
But the seasonal reality matters. Over the last two years, Anthem Highlands area homes that sold in October and November averaged between 54 and 75 days on market, and sellers who closed in October and November of 2025 received between about 92% and 94% of their original list price. The later in the season you list, the more time and negotiating room you should plan for. Getting on the market now, in October, gives you the best chance to capture serious buyers before the holiday slowdown sets in.
Mortgage rates are the other piece of the fall picture. Freddie Mac reported the average 30-year fixed rate at 7.40% as of October 15, 2026, up from 6.27% a year earlier. On an $800,000 loan, that difference adds roughly $600 a month to a buyer’s principal and interest payment. That is a big part of why buyers are negotiating harder, and it is why your list price has to reflect what buyers can actually afford today rather than what a neighbor got two years ago.
The demand drivers have not changed. Out-of-state relocation buyers continue to be drawn to Anthem Highlands for the mountain views, the trail networks, and the community infrastructure, including the 32,000-square-foot Parkside Community Center.
Pricing Strategy That Wins in Anthem Highlands This Fall
This is where I see sellers make their most expensive mistake. Let me be direct about what the data shows.
Across Broomfield, sellers received 97.0% of their original list price on homes that closed in September 2026, and the median home took 32 days to sell, which is the slowest September in MLS data going back to 2021. Inside the Anthem Highlands area, the third-quarter figure was about 94% of original list price. That is a market that rewards accuracy and punishes overpricing.
Here is what that looks like in real dollars. On a home originally listed at $1,000,000, the difference between 96% and 94% is about $20,000. Sellers who closed in July and August of this year received closer to 91% of their original price, which on that same $1,000,000 home is a gap of roughly $90,000 from where they started.
What does this mean for your pricing strategy? It means you cannot pad your list price by $50,000 “to leave room for negotiation.” When a home starts too high in this neighborhood, it collects days on market, and long days on market have gone hand in hand with deeper discounts. The strongest results come from pricing at market on day one and letting competition do the work.
Having earned my RENE (Real Estate Negotiation Expert) designation and CLHMS (Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist) certification, I approach pricing your home with a data-first methodology. It is the single most important decision you will make.
What Anthem Highlands Buyers Are Looking For Right Now
Understanding your buyer helps you position your home correctly. Here is what I am seeing.
The typical Anthem Highlands buyer is a dual-income professional household with school-age children. They are drawn to this community for very specific reasons:
- Thunder Vista P-8 is located directly inside the neighborhood and serves preschool through 8th grade within the Adams 12 Five Star Schools district.
- Prospect Ridge Academy, a top-rated K-12 charter school, is within walking distance for many homes.
- Legacy High School, which scores an A overall on Niche, serves the neighborhood within the Adams 12 Five Star Schools district.
- The community offers 48+ miles of trails, 22 parks, a reservoir, and 10 ponds.
- The location puts buyers between Downtown Denver (35 to 40 minutes) and Boulder (20 to 25 minutes).
If your home checks the boxes these buyers care about, including updated finishes, a functional floor plan in the 3,500 to 5,000+ square foot range, and strong outdoor living space, you are in an excellent position.
What I always recommend is that staging and professional photography highlight these lifestyle elements. Buyers relocating from out of state are making decisions from listing photos before they ever book a flight.
How Anthem Highlands Compares to the Rest of Broomfield
Your equity position in Anthem Highlands is worth putting in perspective.
Through September 2026, the average sale price for a single-family home across Broomfield was about $792,000, and the citywide median sale price in September was $715,000, per MLS data. The Anthem Highlands area’s year-to-date average of about $1,007,000 represents roughly a 27% premium over the citywide average. That gap reflects the quality of the community, the school access, and the amenity package.
You are in the premium tier. That means your buyer pool is smaller, but it is highly motivated and financially qualified, and with rates above 7%, those qualified buyers are paying close attention to value.
With 15 five-star reviews and a career production exceeding $100 million, I have represented sellers across Broomfield’s communities and understand exactly how to position an Anthem Highlands listing against the alternatives buyers are touring.
Frequently Asked Questions About Selling in Anthem Highlands This Fall
The average sale price in the Anthem Highlands area was about $1,007,000 for homes that closed from January through September 2026, per MLS data. That is about 5% below the same period in 2025. Because only a handful of homes close each month, monthly medians swing widely, so the year-to-date average is a more reliable read than any single month.
Homes in the Anthem Highlands area averaged about 55 days on market in the third quarter of 2026, compared with about 29 days in the third quarter of 2025, per MLS data. Homes that closed in September averaged 60 days, with a median of 37 days.
It depends on which number you look at. Inventory still favors sellers, with roughly 1.6 months of supply at the end of September 2026, and anything under six months is traditionally considered a seller’s market. Pricing tells a different story, because sellers received about 94% of their original list price in the third quarter and homes took nearly twice as long to sell as a year ago. Buyers have choices on price even though they do not have many homes to choose from.
HOA fees run approximately $174 to $186 per month ($2,160 to $2,219 annually). These cover access to the Parkside Community Center, including indoor and outdoor pools, fitness facilities, and common area maintenance.
Thunder Vista P-8 (preschool through 8th grade) is located inside the neighborhood. Prospect Ridge Academy, a top-rated K-12 charter, is within walking distance for many homes. Legacy High School serves high school students and scores an A overall on Niche.
Fall offers reduced seller competition, with only 8 active listings in the Anthem Highlands area at the end of September 2026. However, homes that sold in October and November over the last two years averaged 54 to 75 days on market and gave up more off their original list price. Listing in October positions you to capture buyers before the holiday slowdown. Spring typically brings more buyers, but it also brings more competing listings, so the right answer depends on your home and your timeline.
Closed sales in the Anthem Highlands area have held roughly flat in the low $230s per square foot year to date in 2026, per MLS data. Monthly figures ranged from $205 to $244 per square foot between July and September, and September closings came in at $205 per square foot.
In the third quarter of 2026, Anthem Highlands area sellers received about 94% of their original list price, down from about 96% in the third quarter of 2025, per MLS data. Homes that closed in September did better at 96.1%, while July and August closings came in near 91%.
Freddie Mac reported the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate at 7.40% as of October 15, 2026, up from 6.27% a year earlier. On an $800,000 loan, that increase adds roughly $600 a month in principal and interest, which directly affects buyer purchasing power at Anthem Highlands price points.
For the 2026 tax year, Colorado assesses residential property at 6.8% of actual value for the local government portion and 7.05% for the school district portion, per the Colorado Division of Property Taxation. Actual values for the 2025 and 2026 tax years are based on sales through June 30, 2024. Your total bill depends on the mill levies of the taxing districts that cover your address.
The Bottom Line for Anthem Highlands Sellers
You are in a strong position. Anthem Highlands inventory is low, sales volume is up about 21% over last year, and buyer demand from relocation purchasers remains consistent. But this market punishes lazy pricing. Homes are taking nearly twice as long to sell as they did a year ago, buyers are working with mortgage rates above 7%, and sellers who started too high this summer gave up close to 9% from their original price.
If you are considering a sale this fall, the window is right now, before days on market stretch further into the holiday season. Price with precision. Present your home to appeal to the professional families who are drawn to Thunder Vista P-8, the 48+ miles of trails, and that quick drive to Boulder.
I am John Grandt with The North Star Team Powered by Real Broker, and I have been helping Broomfield families navigate exactly these decisions since 2017. If you want a data-driven pricing analysis specific to your home on Pacific Peak, Fletcher Mountain Way, or anywhere else in Anthem Highlands, reach out at 720.351.8488. Let’s look at the numbers together.
Looking for a trusted Anthem Highlands real estate team? Work with our Anthem Highlands listing specialist and review recent Anthem Highlands closings first. Call John Grandt and The North Star Team at 720-351-8488.